Updated July 30, 2026 with the latest Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic scores as more reviews have come in.
Reviews for Spider-Man: Brand New Day have continued rolling in, and the film’s Rotten Tomatoes score has climbed since its first wave of reactions, now sitting at 91% based on more than 150 reviews. Critics have landed on a clear consensus: Tom Holland delivers his strongest performance in the role yet, but the film’s real breakout is Sadie Sink, with the reception settling into strong, broadly positive praise just ahead of the film’s July 31 release.
Here’s the current critical consensus, what individual critics are saying, why Sink is getting singled out, and what producer Amy Pascal has said about the story’s themes.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day’s Critical Reception
As of July 30, the film holds a 91% Tomatometer score on Rotten Tomatoes from more than 150 reviews, up from the 88% mark it carried on smaller review counts just two days earlier. Metacritic’s score sits at 70 out of 100, putting it ahead of Spider-Man: Far From Home’s 69 and just behind Spider-Man: Homecoming’s 73, comfortably within the range of the better-reviewed entries in Holland’s run as Peter Parker. Several critics have still flagged the plot as overstuffed, juggling multiple character arcs and villains within a single film rather than keeping its focus tight.
What Individual Critics Are Saying
Reactions vary in enthusiasm even within the overall positive consensus. Variety’s Owen Gleiberman found the film competently made but overlong, describing it as watchable without ever feeling especially transporting. By contrast, The Cinematic Reel’s David Gonzalez called it the closest the modern Spider-Man films have come to capturing the spirit of Sam Raimi’s original trilogy, praising its emotional core. Consequence’s Liz Shannon Miller took a similar view, noting the film sidesteps galaxy-saving stakes to focus tightly on what keeps Peter Parker swinging in the first place.
Tom Holland’s Strongest Outing Yet
The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney called it the strongest of Holland’s four solo performances as Peter Parker, writing that the actor brings soulful new notes to a character rendered more vulnerable by loss. That framing lines up with the film’s broader premise, following Peter as he rebuilds his life after being erased from the world’s memory, giving Holland material that pushes beyond the character’s earlier, lighter register.
Sadie Sink Emerges as the Standout
Across multiple reviews, Sadie Sink has been singled out as the film’s biggest surprise, with critics describing her performance as devastating. Coming from an actress already well known for her work in Stranger Things, reviewers have specifically noted that this role represents a meaningful jump even from her most acclaimed work as Max Mayfield, praising the emotional depth she brings to a role the marketing had deliberately kept vague ahead of release.
What Amy Pascal Has Said About the Film
Producer Amy Pascal has framed Brand New Day’s core theme as being about not wanting to be who you are, describing it as a story about the desire to fit in and the process of learning that being different is okay, and maybe even great. That thematic framing helps explain why critics have responded so strongly to the film’s more vulnerable, identity-focused approach to Peter Parker’s story, rather than treating it purely as another action-driven blockbuster entry.
Why the Overstuffed Plot Criticism Matters
Despite the strong overall reception, the recurring criticism about the film’s plot juggling too many threads at once is worth taking seriously heading into wider release. Several reviews have specifically flagged the film as ambitious to a fault, suggesting that while individual performances and themes land well, the film’s structure may not fully support everything it’s attempting to do within a single runtime.
How This Compares to Past Spider-Man Reviews
A 91% score puts Brand New Day in strong company among Holland’s four solo Spider-Man films, though the specific praise this time reads differently than past reviews. Where earlier entries were often celebrated for their humor and lighter emotional stakes, critics discussing Brand New Day have repeatedly reached for words like mature, vulnerable, and devastating, suggesting the franchise has genuinely shifted its emotional register rather than simply delivering another crowd-pleasing installment with the same tone as before.
What This Means Heading Into Release
With reviews landing strongly positive just a day before the film’s July 31 theatrical release, Spider-Man: Brand New Day heads into its opening weekend with real critical momentum behind it, anchored by Holland’s performance and Sink’s breakout turn. That critical reception is separate from, though closely watched alongside, the film’s box office tracking, which has become one of the most closely followed storylines of the year in its own right.
FAQ: Spider-Man Brand New Day Reviews
What is Spider-Man: Brand New Day’s current Rotten Tomatoes score?
As of July 30, the film holds a 91% Tomatometer score based on more than 150 reviews.
What is Spider-Man: Brand New Day’s Metacritic score?
The film sits at 70 out of 100 on Metacritic, ahead of Spider-Man: Far From Home’s 69 and just behind Spider-Man: Homecoming’s 73.
Which actor is getting the most praise in reviews?
Sadie Sink has emerged as the film’s standout, with critics calling her performance devastating and a significant jump from her acclaimed Stranger Things work.
What has producer Amy Pascal said about the film’s themes?
Pascal described the film as being about not wanting to be who you are, framing it as a story about learning that being different can be a good thing.
For more on the film’s rollout, see our coverage of its UK release, Sadie Sink’s mystery role, and our box office tracking breakdown.
More on the film is available on Wikipedia and Rotten Tomatoes.
Once you have seen it, read ShowPulp’s Spider-Man: Brand New Day ending and post-credit scene explained for a full breakdown of Jean Grey’s fate and that final stinger.
{“@context”:”https://schema.org”,”@type”:”FAQPage”,”mainEntity”:[{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”What is Spider-Man: Brand New Day’s current Rotten Tomatoes score?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”As of July 30, the film holds a 91% Tomatometer score based on more than 150 reviews.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”What is Spider-Man: Brand New Day’s Metacritic score?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”The film sits at 70 out of 100 on Metacritic, ahead of Spider-Man: Far From Home’s 69 and just behind Spider-Man: Homecoming’s 73.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”Which actor is getting the most praise in reviews?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”Sadie Sink has emerged as the film’s standout, with critics calling her performance devastating and a significant jump from her acclaimed Stranger Things work.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”What has producer Amy Pascal said about the film’s themes?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”Pascal described the film as being about not wanting to be who you are, framing it as a story about learning that being different can be a good thing.”}}]}
